Mouth Watering Porcini Substitute For Your Family

Porcini Substitute: Did you go to the store to buy porcini mushrooms and got disappointed as they are not available? Or are you looking for the best substitute for porcini mushrooms as they are a bit pricey to buy them?

Did you think that the mushrooms that you have will be enough to make pasta but aren’t they enough for the recipe? Whatever the situation may be, the only thing you are looking for is the porcini mushroom substitute that replaces the porcini by giving a similar taste.

Mostly, you cannot find them in the stores anytime you want as they are seasonal. Porcini mushrooms are best in taste with a lot of health benefits.

Looking into the blog post that we have provided below can give you an idea of what porcini substitute works well in the recipes along with some other interesting information. Without any further delay, just scroll down, and read!!

What is Porcini Mushroom?

Porcini mushroom is a mushroom that is edible with a strong and intense flavor. These mushrooms are available in the stores in both fresh and dried.

Porcini mushrooms are unique in flavor but it is a bit pricey. Porcini mushrooms can also be called boletus or ceps. It is closely related to the Boletaceae family. 

Porcini mushrooms are mostly available in European regions like France and Italy. It can add flavor to many dishes like sauces, pasta, and soups. But they are good if you fry them with some salt and oil or even roast them with some olive oil. 

7 Best Porcini Mushroom Substitutes - What To Use Instead of Porcini Mushrooms

  • Portobello Mushroom
  • Shiitake Mushrooms 
  • Button Mushrooms
  • Oyster Mushrooms
  • Dried Shiitake Mushrooms
  • Dried Thyme
  • Dried Chanterelle Mushrooms

If you cannot find the porcini mushrooms or you dont want to buy them but you need some similar taste of it? then these substitutes are the best alternatives to porcini mushrooms. 

Here we have provided you with all the substitutes for fresh and dried porcini. We will look into the one-by-one substitute of porcini.

Fresh Mushroom Substitutes For Fresh Porcini

Don't worry, if you can't able to find the porcini mushrooms as we are providing some of the best alternatives to fresh porcini. Look into them below.

  • Portobello Mushroom
  • Shiitake Mushrooms 
  • Button Mushrooms
  • Oyster Mushrooms

Portobello Mushroom

Coming to these portobello mushrooms it is an exact alternative to the fresh porcini mushrooms as they have similar flavor and texture. And wonder to know that, these are the best meat substitute as they have a meaty texture.

They are somewhat large in size and add the best umami flavor to the dish. You can use them in soups, stews, as burger patties, or to prepare gravy and for many dishes where porcini is used. And these mushrooms can find all year long. 

Shiitake Mushrooms

Need the best substitute for porcini to replace it? Then shiitake mushrooms are the best alternative to the porcini and it is a good choice.

Because, shiitake mushrooms as cheaper than porcini and gives the same earthy umami flavor, texture, and even look. These mushrooms are available in different colors. 

Shiitake mushrooms are also called winter mushrooms and you can use them best for gravies, risotto, stews, pies, soups, pasta, or any other dish as these mushrooms will hold up well. 

Button Mushrooms

One more alternative to porcini is button mushrooms and it is the best common alternative that can be found anywhere in any store. But these are having less meaty texture compared to porcini and others but it has the same umami and earthy flavor.

Button mushrooms are very affordable but they are seasonal like porcini. As they are small in size when the recipe calls for 1 cup of porcini you need to use 2 cups or the quantity that you like but you need to use more for the same flavor.

You can use these in any type of dish that uses porcini. 

Related Articles:

Oyster Mushrooms

One more alternative for porcini is oyster mushrooms. These are popular mushrooms because of their look, and meaty texture. As it has an umami flavor they are commonly used in Asian cuisines.

You can use these mushrooms in stir-fries, soups, stews, sauces, and pizza toppings. These mushrooms are quite pricey but will be available in any supermarket.

You can use the same amount of oyster mushrooms in place of porcini. 

Dried Mushroom Substitutes For Dried Porcini

Till now, we have seen fresh mushroom substitutes that give an exact flavor of fresh porcini. Now, we are going to have a look at the dried mushroom substitutes for dried porcini.

Dried Porcini will be available in the markets but if you cannot afford them you can use these substitutes which are affordable and of similar taste.

  • Dried Shiitake Mushrooms
  • Dried Thyme
  • Dried Chanterelle Mushrooms

Dried Shiitake Mushrooms

The best affordable alternative to the dried porcini is the dried shiitake mushrooms as we have already discussed fresh mushrooms, it has the same taste and texture with an earthy and umami flavor as porcini mushrooms.

You can use dried shiitake in the same amount to replace the dried porcini. You can use them best for soups, stir-fries, Sauces, risotto, and pasta. 

Dried Thyme

Dried thyme is the best alternative to dried porcini as it gives you umami and a warm flavor. Thyme gives you a slightly bitter taste but using half a teaspoon in your dish will make you feel like you are eating porcini.

It is best to use in fish dishes, poultry, sauces, meat, and cream sauces. 

Dried Chanterelle Mushrooms

Another popular alternative to dried porcini mushrooms is dried chanterelle mushrooms. You will have a similar taste to dried porcini when you add it to the dishes. You can use them in the same amount and in all the dishes where you use dried porcini mushrooms.

If you want you can rehydrate them and use them in the cuisines and it takes the same amount of time like dried porcini to rehydrate. 

FAQs on Porcini Mushroom Substitute

Key Outcomes

We hope that the information we have gathered for you on the porcini substitute has shed some light on you. Use the substitutes that you like and that is good for your recipe.

Once after trying it do comment to us did you get a similar flavor or not. Still, for any doubts and suggestions, do comment below, and we will answer ASAP.

For more other substitutes, stay in touch with our website.

Porcini Substitutes

By Dr. Steven Smith MS, RDN, CNSC

Try these porcini substitutes and enjoy your food with your family as it tastes same even though if you don't have porcini mushrooms

Porcini Substitutes
Prep Time
05 minutes
Cook Time
05 minutes
Total Time
10 minutes


  • Cremini Mushrooms
  • Tomato Paste


  • 1 Cremini Mushrooms
    • 1 To Substitute Cremini mushrooms in place of porcini mushrooms, you can use the same amount or you can use according your preference.
  • 2 Tomato Paste
    • 1 When your recipe calls for porcini mushrooms, add the same of or less amount of tomato paste, so that you can enjoy porcini mushrooms with tomato flavor.


Measurements can vary based on your taste preferences and also recipe types.